Brown’s Professor Loury speaks out about our “race reckoning” in a way that the Left needs to hear.
His comments are food for the mind — for all.
Unspeakable Truths about Racial Inequality in America
Loury speaks the unspeakable:
Downplaying behavioral disparities by race is actually a “bluff.”
“Seeing prisons as a racist conspiracy to confine black people is an absurd proposition. No serious person could believe it. Not really. Indeed, it is self-evident that those taking lives on the streets of St. Louis, Baltimore, Philadelphia, and Chicago are, to a man, behaving despicably. Moreover, those bearing the cost of such pathology, almost exclusively, are other blacks. An ideology that ascribes this violent behavior to racism is laughable. Of course, this is an unspeakable truth, but no writer or social critic, of whatever race, should be canceled for saying so.”
TUDOR PLACE: The two sides of the racist coin are INTERGENERATIONAL WHITE BIGOTRY and the PATHOLOGY OF THE URBAN BLACK NEIGHBORHOOD. Both must go.
“Structural racism” isn’t an explanation — it’s an empty category.
“The invocation of ‘structural racism’ in political argument is both a bluff and a bludgeon. It is a bluff in the sense that it offers an “explanation” that is not an explanation at all and, in effect, dares the listener to come back . . .
“And it is a bludgeon in the sense that use of the phrase is mainly a rhetorical move. Users don’t even pretend to offer evidence-based arguments beyond citing the fact of the racial disparity itself. The ‘structural racism’ argument seldom goes into cause and effect. Rather, it asserts shadowy causes that are never fully specified, let alone demonstrated. We are all just supposed to know that it’s the fault of something called “structural racism,” abetted by an environment of “white privilege,” furthered by an ideology of “white supremacy” that purportedly characterizes our society. It explains everything. Confronted with any racial disparity, the cause is “structural racism.”
TUDOR PLACE: No one denies that there STILL IS racism in this country, but to ABSTRACT IT into reified concepts which quickly devolve into hollow slogans — SIGNS WITHOUT REFERENTS — is to ENTRENCH the problem rather than DEAL WITH IT. It also keeps blacks PERMANENTLY AGGRIEVED while relieving them of ANY RESPONSIBILITY in coming to terms with THEIR OWN RACISM in an increasingly DIVIDED society they, too, are now PERPETUATING.
We must put the police killings of black Americans into perspective.
“There are about 1,200 fatal shootings of people by the police in the U.S. each year, according to the carefully documented database kept by the Washington Post, which enumerates, as best it can determine, every single instance of a fatal police shooting. Roughly 300 of those killed are African Americans, about one-fourth, while blacks are about 13% of the population. So that’s an over-representation, though still far less than a majority of the people who are killed. More whites than blacks are killed by police in the country every year. You wouldn’t know that from the activists’ rhetoric.”
“To put it in perspective, there are about 17,000 homicides in the U.S. every year, nearly half of which involve black perpetrators. The vast majority of those have other blacks as victims. For every black killed by the police, more than 25 other black people meet their end because of homicides committed by other blacks. This is not to ignore the significance of holding police accountable for how they exercise their power vis-a-vis citizens. It is merely to notice how very easy it is to overstate the significance and the extent of this phenomenon, precisely as the Black Lives Matter activists have done.”
TUDOR PLACE: A Filipino-American died some time last year as a result of a policeman KNEELING ON HIS NECK. The crime was IDENTICAL to the one committed by Derek Chauvin on George Floyd. Yet, the story was never aired by the MSM. Nor have any MURALS been painted to memorialize the dead Filipino-American. Did his life not matter?
There is a dark side to the “white fragility” blame game.
“One risks cancellation for saying this, but the right idea is the idea of Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr.: to transcend our racial particularism while stressing the universality of our humanity. That is, the right idea, if only fitfully and by degrees, is to carry on with our march toward the goal of “race blindness,” to move toward a world where no person’s worth is seen to be contingent upon racial inheritance. This is the only way to address a legacy of historical racism effectively without running into a reactionary chauvinism. Promoting anti-whiteness, and Black Lives Matter often seems to flirt with this, may cause one to reap what one sows in a backlash of pro-whiteness. Here we have yet another unspeakable truth, which, as a responsible black intellectual, it is my duty to apprise you of.“
TUDOR PLACE: The pro-whiteness backlash is already here and rapidly gaining traction. What could be more counterproductive to those seeking to END RACISM? And it begs the question of whether the Left is just as interested in PERPETUAL POLARIZATION as the Right. Provoking backlashes certainly keeps RACE BAITING going on both sides. And for some, that’s a LUCRATIVE BUSINESS.
“Black fragility” is a form of infantilization.
“When you take agency away from people, you remove the possibility of holding them to account and the capacity to maintain judgment and standards so that you can evaluate what they do.“
“What is more, there is a deep irony in first declaring white America to be systemically racist but then mounting a campaign to demand that whites recognize their own racism and deliver blacks from its consequences. I want to say to such advocates: ‘If, indeed, you are right that your oppressors are racists, why would you expect them to respond to your moral appeal? You are, in effect, putting yourself on the mercy of the court while simultaneously decrying that the court is unrelentingly biased.’ The logic of such advocacy escapes me.“
TUDOR PLACE: Let’s be clear here. The entire BLM/CRT initiative is a DEMAND for a SECOND EMANCIPATION. This time, with REPARATIONS. Trouble is, BLACKS ARE NO LONGER IN CHAINS. BY LAW, they have as much EQUALITY OF OPPORTUNITY as other Americans, including naturalized citizens WHO, BY AND LARGE, outperform them. Still, is Glenn Loury not LIVING PROOF that blacks can MAKE IT?
Whites cannot “give” blacks equality.
“Take responsibility for your life. No one’s coming to save you. It’s not anybody else’s job to raise your children. It’s not anybody else’s job to pick the trash up from in front of your home. Take responsibility for your life. It’s not fair, and this is another, I think, delusion. People think there is some benevolent being up in the sky who will make sure everything works out fairly, but it is not so. Life is full of tragedy and atrocity and barbarity and so on. This is not fair. It is not right. But such is the way of the world.”
“If we blacks want to walk with dignity, if we want to be truly equal, then we must realize that white people cannot give us equality.”
TUDOR PLAZA: Nor is it white people’s RESPONSIBILITY. Plus, until blacks EMANCIPATE THEMSELVES from both what RESIDUAL BIGOTRY REMAINS as well as the PATHOLOGY of much of URBAN BLACK CULTURE, they’re as DEPENDENT on MASSA as ever. And it’s that PSYCHOLOGICAL DEPENDENCE which now must be broken. What was it Billie Holiday sang?
“God Bless the child that’s got his own.”




