Another powerful — AND INTENSELY LOGICAL — rebuttal of the notion that we can IMMEDIATELY START DECARBONIZING. And it’s from Gail Tverberg, A BRILLIANT ACTUARY, who also knows a lot about energy.
Here’s her opening line — and it’s a SALVO:
“One of the great misconceptions of our time is the belief that we can move away from fossil fuels if we make suitable choices on fuels.”
She continues:
“The problem is the same regardless of what lower bound a person chooses: our economy is way too dependent on consuming an amount of energy that grows with each added human participant in the economy. This added energy is necessary because each person needs food, transportation, housing, and clothing, all of which are dependent upon energy consumption. The economy operates under the laws of physics, and history shows disturbing outcomes if energy consumption per capita declines.“ (my italics and underscoring)
Fleshing out this claim, she writes — and this is verbatim:
-
The impact of alternative energy sources is smaller than commonly believed.
-
When countries have reduced their energy consumption per capita by significant amounts, the results have been very unsatisfactory.
-
Energy consumption plays a bigger role in our lives than most of us imagine.
-
It seems likely that fossil fuels will leave us before we can leave them.
-
The timing of when fossil fuels will leave us seems to depend on when central banks lose their ability to stimulate the economy through lower interest rates.
-
If fossil fuels leave us, the result could be the collapse of financial systems and governments.
Here’s the entire piece:
The True Feasibility of Moving Away from Fossil Fuels
And here are the eight prongs of her thesis — again in her words:
-
[1] Wind, water and solar provide only a small share of energy consumption today; any transition to the use of renewables alone would have huge repercussions.

-
[2] Venezuela’s example (Figure 1, above) illustrates that even if a country has an above average contribution of renewables, plus significant oil reserves, it can still have major problems.
-
[3] When individual countries have experienced cutbacks in their energy consumption per capita, the effects have generally been extremely disruptive, even with cutbacks far more modest than the target level of 80% to 90% that we would need to get off fossil fuels. (my underscoring)
-
[4] Most people are surprised to learn that energy is required for every part of the economy. When adequate energy is not available, an economy is likely to first shrink back in recession; eventually, it may collapse entirely. (my underscoring)
-
[5] If the supply of energy to an economy is reduced for any reason, the result tends to be very disruptive . . . .
-
[6] Most people assume that moving away from fossil fuels is something we can choose to do with whatever timing we would like. I would argue that we are not in charge of the process. Instead, fossil fuels will leave us when we lose the ability to reduce interest rates sufficiently to keep oil and other fossil fuel prices high enough for energy producers. (my underscoring)
-
[7] Once we hit the “no more stimulus impasse,” fossil fuels will begin leaving us because prices will fall too low for companies extracting these fuels. They will be forced to leave because they cannot make an adequate profit. (my underscoring)
-
[8] Conclusion: We can’t know exactly what is ahead, but it is clear that moving away from fossil fuels will be far more destructive of our current economy than nearly everyone expects. (my underscoring)
For those who haven’t figured it out, we’re charging into that dreaded box canyon with Colonel Thursday. Even as we parse pronouns, multiply genders, weaponize “theories” and LIVE LIKE THERE’S NO TOMORROW.
Folks, it’s this simple:
“Once the Federal Reserve and other central banks lose their ability to cut interest rates further to support the need for ever-rising oil prices, the danger is that oil and other commodity prices will fall too low for producers.”
ZERO INTEREST RATES, ZERO PRODUCTION, ZERO OIL, ZERO ECONOMY.