Whoa! Does this dude come loaded for bear!
What a complete dismantling, starting with his nullification of the “PROJECT’S” basic premise, i.e. that the US was founded to perpetuate slavery when, in fact, many of the original inhabitants of this country wished to OUTLAW it.
I’ve said all along that the 1619 Project was nothing more than an IDEOLOGICAL PUFF-PIECE POORLY OUTFITTED IN HISTORICAL DRAG. There was ZERO SCHOLARSHIP but only a LITANY OF GRIEVANCES stemming from events PRIOR TO THE CIVIL RIGHS ERA.
Jilani, who by the way is unusually bright and extremely fluent, calls the “PROJECT” both liturgy and a catechism. And given that a company such as SHELL OIL is nominally in support only proves that nothing will be achieved by it other than the ENSHRINEMENT of the notion of STRUCTURAL RACISM as some immutable, immovable bugaboo. JEEPERS!
As we know, when Corporate America gets behind anything like this, it’s always AT NO COST TO IT AND UNLIKELY TO CHANGE ANYTHING. It merely allows the money-power axis more room to maneuver until the next time it’s required to deliver a HOT-AIR SOLUTION to something. In other words, it’s PURE P.R.
Jilani also points out that a) the FAR LEFT were first on the political spectrum to take issue with the PROJECT’S nonsense and b) Native American groups also found much of it ABSURD.
But watch for yourself. It’s only 12:26, and Jilani truly TELLS IT.
Zaid Jilani Explains What’s Wrong with the NYT’s 1619 Project
Shallow and ideological, the 1619 Project was in every respect a fraudulent stunt by both Nikole Hannah-Jones and the New York Times.
SHAME ON THEM BOTH!